媒体：特朗普签署备忘录将对中国商品大规模征收关税

Artificial intelligence is reshaping the business landscape at an unprecedented pace. For consultancies, cloud providers, and digital-native firms, AI represents the next logical step in a long-term investment strategy. But for many marketing and creative agencies, the rush into AI is less a leap forward and more a lifeline. It is not a transformation—it is a performance, and in many cases, a desperate one.

Across the industry, agencies are loudly declaring their embrace of AI, offering new toolkits, services, and strategic frameworks. But the substance behind these declarations is often shallow. For agencies long tethered to media execution and creative development, AI represents not a natural evolution, but a foreign terrain—one that demands capabilities they have neither built nor acquired.

AI as Capability, Not Campaign

True AI integration is a capability play, not a campaign stunt. It requires an enterprise-wide transformation, encompassing cloud infrastructure, access to large and high-integrity datasets, in-house machine learning expertise, continuous model training, and rigorous governance frameworks. These are not assets that can be retrofitted quickly or procured externally without organizational change.

Leading consultancies and technology companies have spent over a decade investing in these foundational elements—establishing internal AI labs, acquiring analytics firms, and integrating AI into core workflows. In contrast, most agencies have made limited moves beyond surface-level automation and pilot experimentation.

A recent Precisely survey found that 60% of organizations cite a lack of expertise and resources as the primary barrier to AI implementation. Meanwhile, S&P Global reports that 42% of AI initiatives were abandoned in the past year, mainly due to misalignment between ambition and capability. When even enterprises with internal IT departments struggle to implement AI meaningfully, the notion that legacy agencies can become credible AI players overnight is, at best, wishful thinking.

The Agency Playbook: Branding Over Building

Too often, agency attempts at AI transformation follow a familiar pattern: bold messaging, rapid rollout of lightly rebranded offerings, and vague claims about proprietary tools. However, behind the scenes, little of the necessary infrastructure is in place.

Take, for example, a well-known digital agency that was initially lauded for its early dominance in performance marketing and later acquired by a larger media conglomerate. After years of leadership churn, account erosion, and a declining footprint in strategic conversations, it has recently repositioned itself around artificial intelligence.

On paper, its transformation sounds credible: “AI-powered content engines,” “intelligent digital twins,” and predictive design frameworks headline its narrative. However, in practice, these offerings seem to be marketing wrappers around third-party tools, with no evidence of proprietary algorithms, in-house machine learning (ML) talent, or significant investment in enterprise-grade data infrastructure. The shift is cosmetic—a brand renovation aimed at signaling modernity rather than delivering transformation.

And this is not an isolated case. A growing number of mid-tier agencies—with legacy SEO or creative credentials and limited technical depth—are clinging to AI as a last strategic pivot. For many, it is a story driven not by client demand or differentiated insight, but by existential urgency. They are not competing in AI because they are ready—they are doing it because they no longer know where else to direct their efforts.

Regulatory Scrutiny and Client Disillusionment

This divergence between marketing and execution is not just unsustainable—it’s becoming risky. In March 2024, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) fined two investment advisory firms, Delphia and Global Predictions, for misrepresenting their AI capabilities. The term "AI washing" has entered the regulatory and commercial vernacular, signifying growing consequences for overstated claims.

For agencies, the implications are particularly acute. Trust is their most fragile currency. And in a world where CMOs are under pressure to deliver measurable ROI, clients are becoming more skeptical of vague “intelligent” offerings that cannot demonstrate tangible business value.

Gartner’s 2025 CMO Spend Survey already signals the shift: 55% of CMOs cited “lack of technical expertise” as a top reason for pulling work from agencies. Many are reallocating AI budgets toward in-house teams or trusted transformation partners in consulting and tech. The message is clear: posturing won’t protect against irrelevance—results will.

Strategic Realignment, Not Superficial Rebranding

There is a viable path forward for agencies—but it requires fundamental rethinking, not cosmetic adaptation.

Agencies that wish to survive and thrive in the AI era must:

• Build real technical capability: This means hiring, not outsourcing, data scientists, engineers, AI ethicists, and technologists capable of collaborating across disciplines.
• Design for continuous integration: AI is not a one-off campaign asset—it is an iterative, self-improving system. Agencies must embed it into operations, measurement, and experience design.
• Prioritize transparency and humility: Clients now expect to understand the AI supply chain. Agencies must be honest about what is proprietary, what is licensed, and what is aspirational.
• Redefine their role: Agencies should not try to become consultancies or cloud vendors. Their differentiated value lies in orchestrating human insight, brand storytelling, and behavior design—areas where AI can accelerate, but not originate.

The Cost of Pretending

AI is not a branding trend. It is a foundational capability that will determine which firms lead and which fade. The creative and marketing industries are at an inflection point. Agencies that embrace AI as infrastructure—deeply, deliberately, and transparently—have a future. Those who treat it as a veneer will find themselves edged out by players with the technical muscle, organizational maturity, and strategic clarity to deliver lasting impact.

Relevance in the AI era won’t be earned through positioning decks. It will be gained through capability, candor, and client outcomes. Until then, many agencies would do well to hit pause on the AI headlines—and focus instead on rebuilding the credibility and competence needed to make those headlines mean something.

#AI #AIWashing #ArtificialIntelligence #CMO #Strategy #Consulting #Transparency #Transformation #FakeItTilYouMakeIt

?